INFORMATION AND MANAGEMENT

Divergence between the media image of a partner and the actual state of bilateral relations as a problem of contemporary communication studies

Authors

How to cite

GOST Gasanov A. M. Divergence between the media image of a partner and the actual state of bilateral relations as a problem of contemporary communication studies // Environmental Management Issues. 2026. Vol. 5. No. 4. P. 45-55. DOI: 10.25726/e3499-5221-4712-x
APA Gasanov, A. M. (2026). Divergence between the media image of a partner and the actual state of bilateral relations as a problem of contemporary communication studies. Environmental Management Issues, 5(4), 45-55. https://doi.org/10.25726/e3499-5221-4712-x

Abstract

Communication research and media monitoring often treat the tone of news about a partner state as a gauge of bilateral relations, but the fit between this media image and non-media indicators has not been measured across all pairs of states. The study estimates the gap and the coverage characteristics behind it. Open data were combined: GDELT 1.0 coded events for 1,826 sampled days in 2015-2024, UN General Assembly voting agreement and IMF bilateral goods trade. The unit of analysis is a dyad-year, with 47,064 observations covering 187 states. Methods include nested regressions with year fixed effects and two-way clustered errors, a split-half reliability check, within-dyad estimation and a comparison of images in national web domains. Voting and trade account for 1.3% of the variance in tone beyond year effects, compared with 33.6% for attention volume and the share of articles on conflictual events. Coverage of the least covered pairs is 0.81 tone units more positive than the non-media indicators predict, and coverage of the most covered pairs is 0.91 units more negative. Annual changes in tone and in voting agreement move in the same direction half of the time. Differences between the two sides' national media images are 38% attributable to the general tone of each national media system and unrelated to the sides' relative trade. The media image of a partner reflects news selection and national media systems, so as an indicator of relations it needs adjustment for attention, event composition and source tone.

Keywords

media image coverage tone bilateral relations news selection news negativity GDELT UN General Assembly voting

Funding

The authors did not declare any external funding for this research.

References

Aizier A. The theme of partnership between Russia and China as reflected in the media of the two countries: similarities and differences in coverage (based on publications from 2025) // Philological Bulletin. 2026. vol. 5. no. 5. pp. 88-95.

Afanasyev D., Fedorova E., Rogov O. On the influence of news sentiment in international media on the market exchange rate of the Russian ruble: a textual analysis // HSE Economic Journal. 2019. vol. 23. no. 2. pp. 264-289.

Bykova P.I., Korochensky A.P. The formation of the mass media complex of the Union State of Russia and the Republic of Belarus // Issues of Journalism, Pedagogy, Linguistics. 2026. vol. 45. no. 2. pp. 226-237.

Vakarchuk D.O. Opportunities and limitations of using big textual data in domestic and foreign political science: the case of the GDELT database // Bulletin of the Russian State University for the Humanities. Series "Political Science. History. International Relations". 2024. no. 3. pp. 30-46.

Wei Yu., Melnik G.S. Constructing China's national image in the Russian media // Communicology. 2025. vol. 13. no. 1. pp. 55-68.

Istomin I.A. Vox populi, vox Dei? Great powers and voting in the United Nations General Assembly // International Analytics. 2018. no. 2. pp. 7-18.

Kazun A.D. Global news flow. Which countries do Russian media talk about and why? // Politeia: Analysis. Chronicle. Forecast (Journal of Political Philosophy and Sociology of Politics). 2018. no. 4 (91). pp. 90-105.

Kolesnichenko A.V. Criteria for selecting news in contemporary Russian media // Mediascope. 2018. no. 3.

Orabiyi D.O.A. On the problem of lacunarity of the media image of a "distant" country (Nigeria reflected in the mirror of RIA Novosti) // Mediascope. 2021. no. 4.

Tyukaeva T.I. World-political influence of global media in the contemporary world: a constructivist approach // MGIMO University Bulletin. 2017. no. 4 (55). pp. 242-271.

Tian H. The image of Russia in China's national media discourse and audience perception // Bulletin of Kabardino-Balkarian State University: Journalism. Education. Verbal Arts. 2025. vol. 4. no. 4. pp. 70-89.

Bailey M.A., Strezhnev A., Voeten E. Estimating dynamic state preferences from United Nations voting data // Journal of Conflict Resolution. 2017. Vol. 61. no. 2. pp. 430-456.

Jiang H., Sun C., Qin Q. Bilateral political relations and trade gains between countries: perspective from value-added exports // Pacific Economic Review. 2025. Vol. 30. no. 2-3. pp. 91-120.

Schultz F. Using the news to measure international cooperation: evaluating Japan–ROK government cooperation using the GDELT 2.0 event database // Asia-Pacific Journal: Japan Focus. 2026. Vol. 24. Art. e13.

Soroka S., Fournier P., Nir L. Cross-national evidence of a negativity bias in psychophysiological reactions to news // Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences. 2019. Vol. 116. no. 38. pp. 18888-18892.

Issue

Section

INFORMATION AND MANAGEMENT

Metrics

3 views
0 downloads
Want to publish with us?
Submit an article

Similar Articles

You may also start an advanced similarity search for this article.